Repair your garage door or replace it? How to tell

Most garage door problems are repairs. Springs, cables, rollers and motors wear out, and replacing them costs far less than a new door. Firms publish £120 to £400 for new springs and £795 to £1,300 for a new up-and-over door, fitted.

So the question is whether the door itself is sound. You can mostly tell by looking.

Look at the door, not the fault

A straight door on a firm frame is worth repairing, whatever's broken. Springs, cables, rollers and most motor faults are standard parts.

Rust holes, rot, a twisted door or a loose frame mean the door is near the end of its life. A repair might work, but you'll be paying again soon.

When repairing makes sense

  • A spring has broken, or a cable is frayed or off its drum
  • Rollers are worn and the door is noisy or sticks
  • The motor has a fault, but the door works smoothly by hand
  • One panel of a sectional door is dented, and the maker still sells it

When a new door makes sense

  • The door is rusted through, rotten, bent or twisted
  • It's needed repairs again and again
  • You want something it can't give you: insulation for a garage you use as a room, better security, or an electric door that suits a motor better than your old one
  • The opening is changing, such as being widened

A worked example

Say your up-and-over door has a broken spring, and the door is otherwise straight and firm. A spring repair from the firms we checked costs £120 to £400, with a middle price of £260. A new up-and-over door costs £795 to £1,300, with a middle price of £998. If the door is sound, the repair is the better spend, even if the other spring goes in a year or two. Fitters usually replace springs in pairs for that reason.

If the same door were also rusting through at the bottom, the sums change: you'd be paying for a repair on a door that's close to needing replacing anyway.

What to ask a repair firm

  • What exactly is wrong, and what will the repair include?
  • Is the call-out included in the price?
  • Will you replace both springs, or just the broken one?
  • What guarantee comes with the repair?

More in questions to ask a garage door firm.

Questions

How long does a garage door last?

It depends far more on the door and how it's looked after than on its age. Springs wear out after a number of openings, so a door used several times a day needs them sooner. A steel door kept free of rust can last decades.

Is it worth repairing an old up-and-over door?

Often, if the panel is straight and the frame is firm. Springs, cables and rollers are standard parts for most up-and-over doors. If the door is rusted through or twisted, a new one is usually better value.

Can a repair firm tell me honestly whether to replace it?

A good one will. Ask what's wrong, what the repair includes and how long they'd expect it to last. If a firm that also sells doors says replace, ask them to show you why.

Coming soon

We're not taking garage door jobs yet. When we do, it'll be a few questions, with help at each one, and photos from your phone.

Coming soon